Maybe Garrett should start

Vick sucks. He had that one good game of late but the last two have been awful. Unless he's doing things defensively that I don't see I don't get why he still plays so much. Lazy passes and general lack of enthusiasm. It's ridiculous.

Garrett on the other hand had been very impressive. His defense is awesome! I say start him and see how Vick does off the bench.

I hate hearing "Vick sucks" because you never know who reads this stuff, how it gets passed around, and most importantly what else might be going on behind the scenes personally, health wise, or in any number of areas.

That said, he's clearly not playing anywhere near his potential, he lacks energy and it's a crapshoot every time he throws a pass, almost as if he doesn't know what's SUPPOSED to be happening.

Garrett is the opposite: lots of energy, lots of effort, solid defense and BECAUSE he's not necessarily a shooter he's willing to drive and slash (which Vick SHOULD be doing but doesn't).

So yeah, give Garrett his starting slot.

True on "Dave's house, Dave's rules."

I was more talking about the generality of the statement. He's playing poorly right now. He's played well at times. Neither have any reflection, necessarily, on him as a 20 year old kid.

But yeah, start Garrett until he figures things out.